ABSTRACT

Choi, Yeon Hee, Herim Ahn and Jinyoung Lee. 2018. Anaphora resolution strategies in L2 reading. Korean Journal of English Language and Linguistics 18-4, 395-422. This paper aims to investigate L2 learners’ strategies for anaphora resolution in reading by L2 proficiency levels and academic backgrounds and by anaphora types and inferential complexity levels of anaphoric ties. Data was collected using think-aloud protocols and mouse movements captured on the computer screen of 16 Korean EFL college students performing an anaphora resolution test. The participants were recruited from two proficiency levels and two academic disciplinary areas. Results revealed dominant anaphora resolution strategies shared by the participants due to the nature of anaphora resolution and simulated testing context, such as reading the prior sentence and translating the target sentence, regardless of anaphora types. Yet, they also presented variations in anaphora resolution strategy use by anaphora and reader variables. For pronouns with low ties the L2 students relied on reference chains, whereas syntactic constraints were prevalently deployed for pronouns with high ties. For demonstrative adjectives with low ties repeated noun phrases were preferred antecedents, while use of world knowledge and topic preference appeared as frequent strategies for those with high ties. The lower level students preferred to use semantic knowledge; the higher level ones utilized syntactic and discourse knowledge. The science majors tended to focus on local sentences, while the humanities majors, especially the higher-level students, read the whole passage before identifying the antecedent. Findings from the study suggest certain strategies are preferred depending on anaphora types and levels of ties as well as L2 learners’ proficiency levels and academic backgrounds.

KEYWORD

anaphora, anaphora resolution, pronoun, demonstrative adjective, antecedent, reference, cohesion, cognitive process, strategies, L2 reading, EFL reading

REFERENCES(50)open

  1. [book] Alderson, J. C. / 1996 / Teaching Reading Skills in a Foreign Language / Macmillan Heinemann : 212 ~ 228

  2. [report] Anderson, R. C. / 1977 / Schema-Directed Processes in Language Comprehension

  3. [jounal] Ariel, M. / 1994 / Interpreting anaphoric expressions: A cognitive versus a pragmatic approach / Journal of Linguistics 30 (1) : 3 ~ 42

  4. [jounal] Arnold, J. E. / 2001 / The effect of thematic roles on pronoun use and frequency of preference continuation / Discourse Processes 31 (2) : 137 ~ 162

  5. [thesis] Bensoussan, M. / 1984 / Aspects of Cohesion and Coherence in Context: Investigating Causes of Difficulty of Israeli University Students Reading Texts in English

  6. [thesis] Berkemeyer, V. C. / 1991 / The Effect of Anaphora on the Cognitive Processing and Comprehension of Readers of German at Various Levels of Baseline German Language Ability

  7. [confproc] Brennan, S. E. / 1987 / A centering approach topronouns / Proceedings of the 25th annual meeting on Association for Computational Linguistics : 155 ~ 162

  8. [jounal] Carrell, P. L. / 1984 / Schema theory and ESL reading : Classroom implications and applications / The Modern Language Journal 68 (4) : 332 ~ 343

  9. [jounal] Carrell, P. L. / 1987 / Content and formal schemata in ESL reading / TESOL Quarterly 21 (3) : 461 ~ 481

  10. [jounal] Choi, Y. H. / 1992 / Co-referential forms in English narrative text / Korean Journal of Applied Linguistics 5 : 63 ~ 89

  11. [book] Cohen, A. D. / 2006 / Strategies in Responding to the New TOEFL Reading Tasks / Educational Testing Service

  12. [jounal] Ian Cunnings / 2015 / Structural constraints on pronoun binding and coreference: evidence from eye movements during reading / Frontiers in Psychology 6 : 840

  13. [thesis] De la Fuente, I. / 2015 / Putting Pronoun Resolution in Context: The Role of Syntax, Semantics, and Pragmatics in Pronoun Interpretation

  14. [jounal] Demel, M. C. / 1990 / The relationship between overall reading comprehension and comprehension of coreferential ties for second language readers of English / TESOL Quarterly 24 (2) : 267 ~ 292

  15. [jounal] Duffy, S. A. / 1990 / Eye movements and anaphor resolution: Effects of antecedent typicality and distance / Language and Speech 33 (2) : 103 ~ 119

  16. [jounal] Elbro, C. / 2017 / Aspects of pronominal resolution as markers of reading comprehension : The role of antecedent variability / Reading & Writing 30 (4) : 813 ~ 827

  17. [jounal] Garrod, S. / 2000 / The contribution of lexical and situational knowledge to resolving discourse roles : Bonding and resolution / Journal of Memory and Language 42 (4) : 526 ~ 544

  18. [confproc] Ge, N. / 1998 / Statistical approach to anaphora resolution / Proceedings of the Sixth Workshop on Very Large Corpora : 161 ~ 170

  19. [book] Givón, T. / 1983 / Topic Continuity in Discourse: A Quantitative Cross-language Study Vol. 3 / John Benjamins Publishing : 1 ~ 42

  20. [book] Grabe, W. / 2002 / Teaching and Researching Reading / Longman Pearson Education

  21. [jounal] Grosz, B. J. / 1995 / Centering: A framework for modeling the local coherence of discourse / Computational Linguistics 21 (2) : 203 ~ 225

  22. [book] Halliday, M. A. K. / 1976 / Cohesion in English / Longman

  23. [book] Halliday, M. A. K. / 1985 / Language, Context, and Text: Aspects of Language in a Social-semiotic Perspective / Oxford University Press

  24. [book] Hirst, G. / 1981 / Anaphora in Natural Language Understanding: A Survey / Springer Verlag

  25. [jounal] Hobbs, J. R / 1978 / Resolving pronoun references / Lingua 44 (4) : 311 ~ 338

  26. [jounal] Joseph, H. S. S. L. / 2015 / Working memory, reading ability and the effects of distance and typicality on anaphor resolution in children / Journal of Cognitive Psychology 27 (5) : 622 ~ 639

  27. [jounal] Kaiser, E. / 2009 / Structural and semantic constraints on the resolution of pronouns and reflexives / Cognition 112 (1) : 55 ~ 80

  28. [thesis] Inhee Kim / 2011 / (A)case study of comprehension-monitoring strategy instruction to EFL readers using the think-aloud procedures

  29. [jounal] 고우경 / 2013 / Anaphora Resolution by EFL Learners: Effects of Grammatical and Thematic Roles / 응용언어학 29 (1) : 1 ~ 36

  30. [jounal] Lappin, S. / 1994 / An algorithm for pronominal anaphora resolution / Computational Linguistics 20 (4) : 535 ~ 561

  31. [jounal] Lee, H. J. / 1989 / Effect of textual cohesion on reading comprehension / English Teaching 37 : 73 ~ 97

  32. [report] MacMillan, F. / 2007 / The role of lexical cohesion in the assessment of EFL reading proficiency

  33. [jounal] McDonald, J. L. / 1995 / The time course of anaphor resolution : Effects of implicit verb causality and gender / Journal of Memory and Language 34 (4) : 543 ~ 566

  34. [jounal] Miltsakaki, E. / 2002 / Towards an aposynthesis of topic continuity and intrasentential anaphora / Computational Linguistics 28 (3) : 319 ~ 355

  35. [confproc] Mitkov, R. / 1997 / Factors in anaphora resolution: They are not the only things that matter: A case study based on two different approaches / Proceedings of a Workshop on Operational Factors in Practical, Robust Anaphora Resolution for Unrestricted Texts : 14 ~ 21

  36. [book] Mitkov, R. / 2005 / The Oxford Handbook of Computational Linguistics / Oxford University Press

  37. [thesis] Moon, S. / 1996 / A Study on Reference-inferential Ability and Strategies in Reading Comprehension: For Korean High School Students

  38. [jounal] Nassaji, H. / 2007 / Schema theory and knowledge-based processes in second language reading comprehension : A need for alternative perspectives / Language Learning 57 (1) : 79 ~ 113

  39. [jounal] Thi Quyen Nguyen / 2017 / Factors Affecting Pronoun Resolution by Vietnamese EFL Learners / 응용언어학 33 (1) : 111 ~ 135

  40. [jounal] Pretorius, E. J. / 2005 / English as a second language learner differences in anaphoric resolution: Reading to learn in the academic context / Applied Psycholinguistics 26 (4) : 521 ~ 539

  41. [jounal] Pretorius, E. J. / 2005 / Reading in a disadvantaged high school : Issues of accomplishment, assessment and accountability / South African Journal of Education 25 (3) : 139 ~ 147

  42. [confproc] Rahman, A. / 2011 / Coreference resolution with world knowledge / Proceedings of the 49th Annual Meeting of the Association for Computational Linguistics: Human Language Technologies 1 : 814 ~ 824

  43. [jounal] Roberts, L. / 2008 / Online pronoun resolution in L2discourse / Studies in Second Language Acquisition 30 (3) : 333 ~ 357

  44. [jounal] Schramm, K. / 2005 / Multimedia transcription of think-aloud data on the L2 reading process / Papers in Applied Linguistic Munster 22

  45. [jounal] 서혜진 / 2016 / L2 Processing of English Pronouns and Reflexives: Evidence from Eye-movements / 영어학 16 (4) : 879 ~ 901

  46. [jounal] Upton, T. A. / 1997 / First and second language use in reading comprehension strategies of Japanese ESL students / The Electronic Journal for English as a Second Language 3 (1)

  47. [jounal] Upton, T. A. / 2001 / The role of the first language in the second language reading / Studies in Second Language Acquisition 23 (4) : 469 ~ 495

  48. [jounal] Van Gompel, R. P. G. / 2004 / Antecedent frequency effects during the processing of pronouns / Cognition 90 (3) : 255 ~ 264

  49. [book] Webber, B. L. / 1980 / Theoretical Issues in Reading Comprehension:Perspectives from Cognitive Psychology, Linguistics, Artificial Intelligence, and Education / Lawrence Erlbaum : 141 ~ 164

  50. [jounal] Winograd, T. / 1972 / Understanding natural language / Cognitive Psychology 3 (1) : 1 ~ 191