ABSTRACT

Purpose – This study aims to investigate the process of political changes in Japan, which has introduced regulatory policies for large-scale retail stores since the 1930s, as well as the examples, and suggests improvement schemes for our policies in Korea, which imposes restrictions on business hours and forced holidays in accordance with the current Distribution Industry Development Act. Research design, data, and methodology – After examining the political change processes related to large-scale retail stores in japan, this study analyzes individually regulated cases based on the ordinances enacted by each local government. Through case analysis in Japan, this study makes political suggestions that may be helpful for our country substantially. Results – Since there is an obvious possibility that our economic restrictions on business hours and mandatory holidays do not coincide with WTO GATS, it is necessary for large-scale distributors to introduce new social and environmental regulations similar to Japan, rather than imposing controls to restrict free competition and also introduce a policy to induce cooperation with small businesses for the advancement of the distribution industry. Thus, it is desirable to take measures on noise, waste, traffic, and parking for the preservation of the living environment in the surroundings when building new large-scale retail stores. It is also important to establish measures to improve the welfare of neighborhood residents and consumers, create a pleasant urban environment, and make it mandatory to make presentations at public hearings among residents. Furthermore, it should be mandatory to establish regional contribution plans when a retail store is established, and take measures to solve various civil complaints or problems that may occur after entering the market. Moreover, it is desirable for large-scale retail stores that entered the market to induce cooperation in performing various activities in the area with a strong sense that they are all members of the local economy. Conclusions – If introducing social regulations like in Japan, there is probably an advantage that the conflicts seen when large-scale retail stores enter the market are absorbed by adjusting the persons concerned within the established institution in order to establish a field to solve such conflicts systematically. In contrast, there are still concerns regarding chaotic operation without any active attempts to have a conversation with large-scale retail stores and local small merchants due to a sharp conflict among the persons concerned, and if it is a briefing session without any decision of the restrictions on their opening itself, there may be doubts with regard to their effectiveness. Moreover, if the de facto opening is restricted by the introduction of such a briefing session procedure, the choice of whether to protect the existing rights of large-scale retail stores might become problematic. However, such problems could be minimized in a way by forming a separate consultative group for all persons concerned including residents, local governments, professionals, civic organizations, small merchants, and massive retail store-related persons.

KEYWORD

Large-Scale Retail Store, Economic Regulation, Social Regulation, Living Environment Considerations, Promotion Of Regional Contributions.

REFERENCES(12)open

  1. [jounal] Hayashi, Masaki / 2010 / Current status and evolution of Japan’s large-scale stores policy / Reference 716 : 73 ~ 90

  2. [web] Japan Small & Medium Business Administration / For Town Planning Regulations Relation to Retail Stores

  3. [book] Kato, Yoshitada / 1996 / Expansion of retail commercial policy / Dobunkan

  4. [book] Minakata, Tatsuaki / 2005 / Distribution policy and the Japanese retail industry / Chuokeizai-Sha

  5. [jounal] Mineo, Miyako / 2008 / Government Regulations on the Large Scale Retail Stores and the Evaluative Frameworks / Journal of Management 71 : 107 ~ 124

  6. [report] National Assembly Research Service / 2009 / Restrictions on Large Retailers : Issues and Alternatives : 45 ~ 52

  7. [book] Tamura, Masanori / 1990 / The end of the large-scale retail stores Law ideology / Nikkei, Inc

  8. [jounal] Watanabe, Tatsuro / 2001 / Efforts of the Town Planning and withdrawal problems of large stores and the like from the city center / Senshu Journal Commerce 73 : 263 ~ 301

  9. [book] Watanabe, Tatsuro / 2007 / A Guide to a Public Policy for Distribution Systems – Reorganization of Distribution Systems and Policy Development / Chuokeizai-sha

  10. [thesis] Yasukura, Ryoji / 2013 / A geographical study on the impact on the city center location and restructuring of large-scale retail stores by the conversion of commercial policy in Japan

  11. [jounal] Yokouchi, Ritsuko / 2006 / Toward the activation of the central city : a review of three urban development laws / Information and research 513 : 1 ~ 10

  12. [jounal] 윤명길 / 2007 / 한국에서의 유통학문 연구 방법론에 대한 소고 / 유통과학연구 5 (1) : 75 ~ 88