ABSTRACT

A s late as the eighteenth century, ordinary jury trial at common law was a judge-dominated, lawyer-free procedure conducted so rapidly that plea bargaining was unnecessary. Thereafter, the rise of adversary procedure and the law of evidence injected vast complexity into jury trial and made it unworkable as a routine dispositive procedure. A variety of factors, some quite fortuitous, inclined nineteenth century common law procedure to channel the mounting caseload into nontrial plea bargaining procedure rather than to refine its trial procedure as contemporary Continental legal systems were doing.

KEYWORD

플리바게닝(Plea Bargaing), 배심재판(Trial by Jury), 비배심재판(Bench Trial), 유죄답변(Guilty Plea), 사인소추(Private Prosecution), 당사자주의 소송절차(Adversary Procedure)

REFERENCES(25)open

  1. [jounal] ARNOLD, F. C. VON / 1855 / Gestandniss statt des Verdicts / Gerichtssaal 7 : 265

  2. [book] BALDWIN, Simeon / 1908 / The American Practice as to Jury Trials in Criminal Cases, In 1 Schwurgerichte und Schofengerichte: Beitrage zu ihrer Kenntnis und Beurteilung : 315

  3. [book] BEAWE, J. M. / 1977 / Crime and the Courts in Surrey: 1736-1753, In Crime in England, 1550-1800 / Princeton University Press

  4. [book] BLACKSTONE, William / 1769 / 4 Commentaries on the Laws of England / Clarendon Press

  5. [jounal] BUFFALO LAW REVIEW / 1974 / Note: The Plea Bargain in Historical Perspective / Bufalo Law Review 23 : 499

  6. [jounal] CASPER, Gerhard / 1972 / Lay Judges in the German Criminal Courts / Journal of Legal Studies 1 : 135

  7. [book] COCKBURN, James S. / 1978 / Trial by the Book? Fact and Theory in the Criminal Process, 1558-1625, In Legal Records and the Historian / Royal Historical Society

  8. [jounal] GOLTDAMMERS ARCHIV / 1870 / Comment: Das Schwurgericht: Gestandniss und Verdikt und Kollision zwischen beiden / Goltdammers Archiv 18 : 530

  9. [book] HALE, Matthew S. / 1736 / 2 The History of the Pleas of the Crown / Nutt

  10. [book] HAY, Douglas / 1975 / Property, Authority and the Criminal Law, In Albion’s Fatal Tree: Crime and Society in Eighteenth-Century England / Allen Lane

  11. [book] JACKSON, Richard M. / 1972 / The Machinery of Justice in England(6th ed. ) / Cambridge University Press

  12. [jounal] LANGBEIN, John H. / 1973 / The Origins of Public Prosecution at Common Law / American Journal of Legal History 17 : 313

  13. [jounal] LANGBEIN, John H. / 1974 / Controlling Prosecutorial Discretion in Germany / University of Chicago Law Review 41 : 439

  14. [book] LANGBEIN, John H. / 1977 / Torture and the Law of Prooj Europe and England in the Ancien Regime / University of Chicago Press

  15. [jounal] LANGBEIN, John H. / 1978 / The Criminal Trial before the Lawyers / University of Chicago Law Review 45 : 263

  16. [book] MACKINNON, F. D. / 1933 / The Law and the Lawyers, In A. S. Turberville / Oxford University Press

  17. [report] / 1966 / PRESIDENT’S COMMISSION ON CRIME IN THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA

  18. [book] RADZINOWICZ, Leon / 1948 / A History of English Criminal Law and Its Administrationfrom / Stevens & Sons Limited

  19. [report] SAN FRANCISCO COMMITTEE ON CRIME / 1970 / A Report on the Criminal Courts of Sun Francisco, Part I: The Superior Court Backlog-Consequences and Remedies

  20. [book] SMITH, Thomas / 1906 / De Republica Anglomm / Cambridge University Press

  21. [jounal] STEPHEN, James F. / 1860 / The Criminal Law and the Detection of Crime / Cornhill Magazine 2 : 697

  22. [book] STEPHEN, James F. / 1883 / A History of the Criminal Law of England / Macmillan and Co

  23. [book] WALTHER, F. / 1851 / Ueber die processualische Wirkung des Gestandnisses im Schwurgerichtsverfahren / Archiv des Criminalrechts : 225

  24. [book] WIGMORE, John H. / 1908 / A General Survey of the History of the Rules of Evidence, In Select Essays in Anglo-American Legal History / Little, Brown

  25. [jounal] WISCONSIN LAW REVIEW / 1952 / Comment: The District Attorney: A Historical Puzzle / Wisconsin Law Review : 125