ABSTRACT

Program logic models has being actively applied to program planning and evaluation in U.S., Canada, and Australia and so on. Some practitioners or researchers, however, do not precisely know the meaning and methods of logic models, just using those as templates. In the meanwhile, Korea is now in the beginning stage in studying logic models, and has the same problems in using those. Therefore, this study selected ‘secondhand smoking free! Seoul program’ as a research case among academic papers and government supported researches, and investigated the problems when applying logic models. As a result, this article has found that the logic model for the secondhand smoking prevention program has exposed several errors, and has the limits in representing the complex realities. For this reason, this study tried to modify the errors of the logic model of the secondhand smoking prevention program, and suggest a more applicable logic model tailored to the complex world, which draws on systems thinking approaches.

KEYWORD

논리모형, 간접흡연, 시스템 사고

REFERENCES(66)open

  1. [confproc] 김동립 / 2010 / 프로그램논리모형의 개념과 유형화에 관한 소고 / 한국정책분석평가학회 공동추계학술대회

  2. [jounal] 김복규 / 2008 / 프로그램 논리모형 설계 및 평가: 농촌활력화사업을 대상으로 / 한국사회와 행정연구 19 (2) : 97 ~ 122

  3. [book] 정주택 / 2008 / 정책평가론 / 법문사

  4. [jounal] 문종열 / 2007 / 금강산관광사업 논리모형과 특성 그리고 정책적 함의 / 한국행정논집 19 (2) : 405 ~ 428

  5. [report] 보건복지부 / 2006 / 재정지원사업의 성과주의 예산제 도입방안

  6. [report] 보건복지부 / 2009 / 2009년도 흡연예방 및 금연클리닉 사업안내

  7. [report] 서미경 / 2006 / 건강증진정책 평가 및 실천방향

  8. [report] 서울시정개발연구원 / 2010 / 간접흡연제로! 서울 평가지표 개발연구

  9. [jounal] 최은진 / 2003 / 간접흡연 감소정책의 방향 / 보건복지포럼

  10. [jounal] 최은진 / 2005 / 간접흡연감소를위한정책과제 / 보건복지포럼

  11. [report] 한국보건산업진흥원 / 2008 / 맞춤형 방문건강관리사업 평가체계개발

  12. [jounal] Batterham, R / 1996 / Can We Achieve Accountability for Long-Term Outcomes in Rehabilitation / Archives of Physical Medicine Rehabilitation 77 (12) : 1219 ~ 1225

  13. [book] Bennett,C / 1976 / Analyzing Impacts of Extension Programs / U.S. Department of Agriculture

  14. [jounal] Bickman,L / 1987 / The Functions of Program Theory / New Directions for Evaluation (33) : 5 ~ 18

  15. [jounal] Bickman,L / 1989 / Barriers to the use of program theory / Evaluation and Program Planning (12) : 387 ~ 390

  16. [jounal] Cato, B / 1998 / Logic Model: A Tool for Planning and Evaluating Health and Recreation Prevention Projects / Journal of Physical Education 69 (8)

  17. [book] Centers for Disease Control and Prevention / 2005 / Introduction to Program Evaluation for Public Health Programs: A Self-study Guide / Centers for Disease Control and Prevention

  18. [book] Chen,H / 1990 / Theory-Driven Evaluations / CA: Sage Publications

  19. [book] Chen,H / 2005 / Practical Program Evaluation: Assessing and improving Planning, Implementation, and Effectiveness / CA: Sage

  20. [jounal] Chen, H / 1983 / Evaluating with Sense: The Theory-driven Approach / Evaluation Review (7) : 283 ~ 302

  21. [jounal] Cooksy, L. J / 2001 / The Program Logic Model as an Integrative Framework for a Multimethod Evaluation / Evaluation and Program Planning (24) : 119 ~ 128

  22. [book] Donaldson, S / 2003 / Theory-driven Program Evaluation in the New Millennium. In Evaluating Social Programs and Problems: Visions for the New Millennium / Lawrence Erlbaum Associates

  23. [book] Donaldson,S / 2007 / Program Theory-Driven Evaluation Science: Strategies and Applications / Taylor & Francis Group

  24. [jounal] Dyehouse, M / 2009 / A Comparison of Linear and Systems Thinking Approaches for Program Evaluation Illustrated Using the Indiana Interdisciplinary GK-12 / Evaluation and Program Planning (32) : 187 ~ 196

  25. [book] Eoyang, G. H / 1998 / Evaluation in a Complex Adaptive System In Managing Complexity in Organizations / CT: Quorum Books

  26. [book] Hatry,H / 1999 / Performance Measurement: Getting Results / Urban Institute Press

  27. [jounal] Kaplan, S / 2005 / The Use of Logic Models by Community-based Initiatives / Evaluation and Program Planning (28) : 167 ~ 172

  28. [book] Kauffman,S.A / 1995 / At Home In The Universe:The Search for the Law of Self-Organization and Complexity / Oxford University Press

  29. [book] Knowlton, L / 2009 / The Logic Model Guidebook / Sage Publications

  30. [jounal] Kurtz, C. F / 2003 / The New Dynamics of Strategy:Sense-making in a Complex and Complicated World / IBM Systems Journal 42 (3) : 462 ~ 483

  31. [jounal] McLaughlin, J / 1999 / Logic Models:A Tool for Telling your Program’s Performance Story / Evaluation and Program Planning (22) : 65 ~ 72

  32. [book] Midgley,G / 2007 / Systems Thinking for Evaluation In Systems Concepts in Evaluation: An Expert Anthology. Point Reyes / EdgePress of Inverness

  33. [jounal] Millar, A / 2001 / Logic Models:A Systems Tool for Performance Management / Evaluation and Program Planning (24) : 73 ~ 81

  34. [book] Mohr,L / 1995 / Impact Analysis for Program Evaluation / CA: Sage Publications

  35. [confproc] Noga, J / 2009 / Logic Models and Systems Models: Two Sides to the Same Coin / presented at AEA Annual Meeting

  36. [web] Office of Management and Budget / Budget Procedures Memorandum No. 861. retrieved from

  37. [jounal] Patton,M / 1989 / A Context and Boundaries for Theory-driven Approach to Validity / Evaluation and Program Planning (12) : 375 ~ 377

  38. [book] Patton,M / 1997 / Utilization-focused Evaluation, 3rd Edition / CA:Sage Publications

  39. [jounal] Patton,M / 1994 / Developmental Evaluation / American Journal of Evaluation (15) : 311 ~ 319

  40. [book] Patton,M / 2010 / Developmental Evaluation:Appling Complexity Concepts to Enhance Innovation and Use / The Guilford Press

  41. [book] Pinnegar,S / 2006 / Are Complex Programs the Best Response to Complex Policy Issues? City Futures Research Centre Issues paper / University of New South Wales

  42. [book] Pope-Davis, D. B / 2010 / The Assessment of Multicultural Counseling Competencies. In Handbook of Multicultural Counseling / CA: Sage

  43. [jounal] Renger, R / 2006 / From Theory to Practice:Lessons learned in the Application of the ATM Approach to Developing Logic Models / Evaluation and Program Planning (29) : 106 ~ 119

  44. [jounal] Renger, R / 2002 / A Three-step Approach to Teaching Logic Models / American Journal of Evaluation 23 (4) : 493 ~ 503

  45. [jounal] Rennekamp, R. A / 2009 / What Progress, Program Evaluation? reflections on a Quarter-Century of Extension Evaluation Practice / Journal of Extension 47 (3)

  46. [book] Rogers, P / 2000 / Causal models in program theory evaluation. In Program Theory in Evaluation: Challenges and Opportunities, New Directions in Program Evaluation / Jossey-Bass Publishers : 47 ~ 55

  47. [jounal] Rogers,P / 2008 / Using Programme Theory to Evaluate Complicated and Complex Aspects of Interventions / Evaluation 14 (1) : 29 ~ 48

  48. [book] Rossi, P. H / 2004 / Evaluation: A Systematic Approach(7th ed.) / CA: Sage

  49. [book] Stacey,R / 1996 / Complexity and Creativity in Organizations / CA: Berrett-Koehler

  50. [jounal] Stufflebeam,D.L / 2001 / The Meta-evaluation Imperative / American Journal of Evaluation 22 (2) : 183 ~ 209

  51. [book] Stufflebeam,D.L / 2004 / The 21st Century CIPP Model in Evaluation Roots / CA: SAGE : 245 ~ 246

  52. [book] Suarez-Balcazar / 2010 / Evaluation Capacity Building: A Cultural and Contextual Framework. In Culture and Disability: Rehabilitation Science and Practice. Sudbury / Jones and Bartlett

  53. [web] Taylor-Powell, E / Enhancing Program Performance with Logic Models. retrieved from

  54. [book] United Way of America / 1996 / Measuring Program Outcomes: A Practical Approach / United Way of America

  55. [book] W.K.Kellogg Foundation / 2004 / Logic Model Development Guide.Bettle Creek,MI:W.K / W. K. Kellogg Foundation

  56. [book] Weiner, D / 2002 / Community Participation and Geographic Information System. In Community Participation and Geographic Information System / Taylor and Francis

  57. [jounal] Weiss,C / 1997 / Theory-based Evaluation: Past, present, and future / New Directions for Evaluation (76) : 41 ~ 55

  58. [book] Weiss,C / 1998 / Evaluation. Upper Saddle River / NJ: Prentice Hall

  59. [book] Westly, F / 2007 / Getting to Maybe: How the World Is Changed / Random House Canada

  60. [book] Westmoreland, H / 2009 / How to Develop a Logic Model for Districtwide Family Engagement Strategies / Harvard Family Research Project․ Harvard Graduate School of Education

  61. [book] Wholey,J / 1979 / Evaluation:Promise and Performance / Urban Institute Press

  62. [book] Wholey,J / 1987 / Evaluability Assessment: Developing Program Theory In Using Program Theory in Evaluation, New Directions for Program Evaluation / CA: Jossey-Bass Publishers : 77 ~ 92

  63. [book] Wholey, J / 1994 / Assessing the Feasibility and likely Usefulness of Evaluation In Handbook of practical program evaluation / Jossey-Bass

  64. [jounal] Wholey,J / 2003 / Using Policy Evaluation to Support Decision Making and Improve Program Performance / Japanese Journal of Evaluation Studies 3 (2) : 6 ~ 11

  65. [web] World Bank / Curbing the Epidemic Governments and the Economics of Tobacco Control. retrieved from

  66. [book] Yarbrough, D. B / 2010 / The Program Evaluation Standards: A Guide for Evaluators and Evaluation Users / CA: Sage